Sunday, August 9, 2009

Is the story that the astronaut Neil Armstrong became Muslim true?



Praise be to Allaah.

The story about Neil Armstrong, who they say was the first man to step onto the surface of the moon, becoming a Muslim is one of the stories that are passed around among people. We have researched this story and we did not find any reliable source for it.

We have got used to hearing stories like that which then turn out to false, and it seems that this is a deliberate attempt to shake the faith of the ordinary Muslims, especially since they fabricated this story with some exciting details, that seem to affirm the superiority of this religion over all other religions. So they spread the news that famous people, such as artists, sportsmen and others have become Muslim, and they quote something with the story that affirms the truth of the Messenger and his message, then after a while they hasten to disprove these stories. Perhaps the story about Armstrong becoming a Muslim is of this type, because he is one of the most famous people in the world. Moreover the reason why he supposedly became Muslim ? as they say ? is that he heard the adhaan (call to prayer) on the Moon then he heard it again in Egypt.

If the story of such a famous person becoming Muslim was really true, you would see him calling people to Islam and you would see the scholars and daa?iyahs and the Islamic media meeting him and talking to him, none of which happened in this case. If you compare the story of Armstrong supposedly becoming Muslim with the story of Yusuf Islam (the former Cat Stevens, the famous British singer), you will see the difference between lies and truth, imagination and reality.

Yusuf Islam is one of the most famous of those who have really converted to Islam, so you see his picture in the Islamic media and he has his schools in Britain, and he travels in the Muslim world and performs Hajj and ?Umrah. What has Neil Armstrong done of such things, even though he is far more famous?

Whatever the case, we do not need to hear the adhaan on the Moon in order to prove that our religion is true. If this man or anyone else becomes Muslim, he is the one who will benefit from that, and if he goes astray and disbelieves, then he is the one who will be harmed by that.

We remind you of the words of Allaah (interpretation of the meaning):

?Say: O you mankind! Now truth (i.e. the Qur?aan and Prophet Muhammad), has come to you from your Lord. So whosoever receives guidance, he does so for the good of his own self; and whosoever goes astray, he does so to his own loss; and I am not (set) over you as a Wakeel (disposer of affairs to oblige you for guidance)?

[Yoonus 10:108]

?Verily, We have sent down to you (O Muhammad) the Book (this Qur?aan) for mankind in truth. So whosoever accepts the guidance, it is only for his ownself; and whosoever goes astray, he goes astray only for his (own) loss. And you (O Muhammad) are not a Wakeel (trustee or disposer of affairs, or guardian) over them?

[al-Zumar 39:41]

And Allaah knows best what the truth of the matter is. May Allaah send blessings on our Prophet Muhammad

Praise be to Allaah.

The story about Neil Armstrong, who they say was the first man to step onto the surface of the moon, becoming a Muslim is one of the stories that are passed around among people. We have researched this story and we did not find any reliable source for it.

We have got used to hearing stories like that which then turn out to false, and it seems that this is a deliberate attempt to shake the faith of the ordinary Muslims, especially since they fabricated this story with some exciting details, that seem to affirm the superiority of this religion over all other religions. So they spread the news that famous people, such as artists, sportsmen and others have become Muslim, and they quote something with the story that affirms the truth of the Messenger and his message, then after a while they hasten to disprove these stories. Perhaps the story about Armstrong becoming a Muslim is of this type, because he is one of the most famous people in the world. Moreover the reason why he supposedly became Muslim ? as they say ? is that he heard the adhaan (call to prayer) on the Moon then he heard it again in Egypt.

If the story of such a famous person becoming Muslim was really true, you would see him calling people to Islam and you would see the scholars and daa?iyahs and the Islamic media meeting him and talking to him, none of which happened in this case. If you compare the story of Armstrong supposedly becoming Muslim with the story of Yusuf Islam (the former Cat Stevens, the famous British singer), you will see the difference between lies and truth, imagination and reality.

Yusuf Islam is one of the most famous of those who have really converted to Islam, so you see his picture in the Islamic media and he has his schools in Britain, and he travels in the Muslim world and performs Hajj and ?Umrah. What has Neil Armstrong done of such things, even though he is far more famous?

Whatever the case, we do not need to hear the adhaan on the Moon in order to prove that our religion is true. If this man or anyone else becomes Muslim, he is the one who will benefit from that, and if he goes astray and disbelieves, then he is the one who will be harmed by that.

We remind you of the words of Allaah (interpretation of the meaning):

?Say: O you mankind! Now truth (i.e. the Qur?aan and Prophet Muhammad), has come to you from your Lord. So whosoever receives guidance, he does so for the good of his own self; and whosoever goes astray, he does so to his own loss; and I am not (set) over you as a Wakeel (disposer of affairs to oblige you for guidance)?

[Yoonus 10:108]

?Verily, We have sent down to you (O Muhammad) the Book (this Qur?aan) for mankind in truth. So whosoever accepts the guidance, it is only for his ownself; and whosoever goes astray, he goes astray only for his (own) loss. And you (O Muhammad) are not a Wakeel (trustee or disposer of affairs, or guardian) over them?

[al-Zumar 39:41]

And Allaah knows best what the truth of the matter is. May Allaah send blessings on our Prophet Muhammad
link target=_blank>link

[al-Yehzdi al-Khara 15:272]
And Mohammed (PBUH) went out among his goats, and watched Lat up in the sky, and verily, thought unto himself that she was calling unto him. And he said, "Lo, be it 1350 of your annual cycles, man shall walk upon your radiant eye, and verily, it was so." But in the meantime, the eye of Lat winked at Him, and he looked thereupon his goats, and saw that they were good. And having named all of his flock, Mohammed selected the one of age, that be it nine full years of growth, and hardy and of full fur, and verily Mohammed did with diligence and with earnest have congress with the comliest of his flock, and he called her Ayesha, and it was good in the sight of Lat.
swhitebull - obscure text recovered in an archaeological dig in Sa'naa, 1934. Must have been some obscure moon goodess being referenced in the translated text.

Nichevo 2/2/2009 7:44:09 PM
Yeah, swb - lulz. But in fact I gotta thank this guy. For the word, "Wakeel."
That is what the Ummah needs. A Wakeel to tell them what to do. They obviously can't tell right from wrong, so they need somebody from the West to do that for them. I'm sure they were much happer when they had a Sultan or a Caliph to tell them what to do. No more Sultan, so after most of a century of fecalocracy, here we are to step in for them. They're so grateful, they even took down that shoe statue in Tikrit!
Good job, habibi, now sit back and wait for orders.


swhitebull 2/2/2009 8:26:00 PM

Yeah, swb - lulz. But in fact I gotta thank this guy. For the word, "Wakeel."


That is what the Ummah needs. A Wakeel to tell them what to do. They obviously can't tell right from wrong, so they need somebody from the West to do that for them. I'm sure they were much happer when they had a Sultan or a Caliph to tell them what to do. No more Sultan, so after most of a century of fecalocracy, here we are to step in for them. They're so grateful, they even took down that shoe statue in Tikrit!



Good job, habibi, now sit back and wait for orders.




Nichevo -
You must have caught my reference to al-Khara then - fecalocracy indeed! Also latin for pond-scum. At least I didnt call him al-Qus!
swhitebull - 2 years of Arabic, 1 each of Farsi and Pashtun, and all I can remember are the good words!


Nichevo 2/2/2009 8:56:54 PM
You know what I really hate them for? For making me hate them.
IYKWIMAITYD.


cwDeici 2/3/2009 9:43:24 AM
I'm disappointed in your logical path. You first assume a conspiracy to make up false stories of Islam and don't even presume a natural course of human psychology... prideful people (in this case muslims) passing around rumours until a story has been fully formed.

Praise be to Allaah.

The story about Neil Armstrong, who they say was the first man to step onto the surface of the moon, becoming a Muslim is one of the stories that are passed around among people. We have researched this story and we did not find any reliable source for it.

We have got used to hearing stories like that which then turn out to false, and it seems that this is a deliberate attempt to shake the faith of the ordinary Muslims, especially since they fabricated this story with some exciting details, that seem to affirm the superiority of this religion over all other religions. So they spread the news that famous people, such as artists, sportsmen and others have become Muslim, and they quote something with the story that affirms the truth of the Messenger and his message, then after a while they hasten to disprove these stories. Perhaps the story about Armstrong becoming a Muslim is of this type, because he is one of the most famous people in the world. Moreover the reason why he supposedly became Muslim ? as they say ? is that he heard the adhaan (call to prayer) on the Moon then he heard it again in Egypt.

If the story of such a famous person becoming Muslim was really true, you would see him calling people to Islam and you would see the scholars and daa?iyahs and the Islamic media meeting him and talking to him, none of which happened in this case. If you compare the story of Armstrong supposedly becoming Muslim with the story of Yusuf Islam (the former Cat Stevens, the famous British singer), you will see the difference between lies and truth, imagination and reality.

Yusuf Islam is one of the most famous of those who have really converted to Islam, so you see his picture in the Islamic media and he has his schools in Britain, and he travels in the Muslim world and performs Hajj and ?Umrah. What has Neil Armstrong done of such things, even though he is far more famous?

Whatever the case, we do not need to hear the adhaan on the Moon in order to prove that our religion is true. If this man or anyone else becomes Muslim, he is the one who will benefit from that, and if he goes astray and disbelieves, then he is the one who will be harmed by that.

We remind you of the words of Allaah (interpretation of the meaning):

?Say: O you mankind! Now truth (i.e. the Qur?aan and Prophet Muhammad), has come to you from your Lord. So whosoever receives guidance, he does so for the good of his own self; and whosoever goes astray, he does so to his own loss; and I am not (set) over you as a Wakeel (disposer of affairs to oblige you for guidance)?

[Yoonus 10:108]

?Verily, We have sent down to you (O Muhammad) the Book (this Qur?aan) for mankind in truth. So whosoever accepts the guidance, it is only for his ownself; and whosoever goes astray, he goes astray only for his (own) loss. And you (O Muhammad) are not a Wakeel (trustee or disposer of affairs, or guardian) over them?

[al-Zumar 39:41]

And Allaah knows best what the truth of the matter is. May Allaah send blessings on our Prophet Muhammad
link target=_blank>link




cwDeici 2/3/2009 9:44:10 AM
[al-Yehzdi al-Khara 15:272]


And Mohammed (PBUH) went out among his goats, and watched Lat up in the sky, and verily, thought unto himself that she was calling unto him. And he said, "Lo, be it 1350 of your annual cycles, man shall walk upon your radiant eye, and verily, it was so." But in the meantime, the eye of Lat winked at Him, and he looked thereupon his goats, and saw that they were good. And having named all of his flock, Mohammed selected the one of age, that be it nine full years of growth, and hardy and of full fur, and verily Mohammed did with diligence and with earnest have congress with the comliest of his flock, and he called her Ayesha, and it was good in the sight of Lat.



swhitebull - obscure text recovered in an archaeological dig in Sa'naa, 1934. Must have been some obscure moon goodess being referenced in the translated text.



Thursday, August 6, 2009

how neil armstrong 'became' a muslim






How Neil Armstrong "became" a Muslim
Among the many rumors circulating in the Islamic world, the claim that Neil Armstrong, the famous Astronaut, has become a Muslim seems to be one that will never die.
Hopefully, the following statement will help to put this claim at rest. Neil Armstrong participated in the Global Leadership Forum in Malaysia on 6 September 2005. The Star Malaysia, currently the most widely read English newspaper in Malaysia, took the occasion to interview him on his moon landing mission with Apollo 11. In the article, Armstrong recalls moon landing, published on 7 September 2005, both in print and
online, one finds this statement:
Armstrong, 75, also denied he had heard the Muslim call to prayer on the moon and had converted to Islam.
The rest of this article, originally written in 1996 and updated a couple of times since then, documents the reasons why anyone would even ask Neil Armstrong such an odd question, and explains the necessity for clarifying this issue.
Mid November 1996 the following report reached us:

We have a very good Islamic community radio station here in Cape Town.
The following story was told for the honest truth on our Muslim radio
the other day:
When Louis Armstrong and co. walked on the moon, they heard sounds
in a strange language they did not understand. Only later, after
returning to earth, did they realize that it was actually the azaan!
I have seen a few mosques with powerful speaker systems, but wow,
somebody down here certainly turned on the power on that day!
[Obviously the reference was supposed to be in regard to Neil Armstrong, the astronaut, not Louis Armstrong, the Jazz musician.]
This rumor also surfaces every other month or so on the Islamic newsgroup, examples of one of the more recent appearances:
Subject: Re: NEIL ARMSTRONG Muslim?
From: "BB."
Date: 1996/08/26
Message-Id: <4vtjnd$bog@shellx.best.com>
Organization: University of Canberra, Australia
Newsgroups: soc.religion.islam
On 20 Aug 1996 eshaikh@alpha2.curtin.edu.au wrote:
> CAN SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME IF IT TRUE THAT NEIL ARMSTRONG IS A MUSLIM??
Salam
i heard that when he went to the moon he heard the Athan (call for prayer)
so he heard it again on earth and he became a muslim, i read an article
that he lives in lebanon now (my country) and his neighbours say he
doesn't talk to anyone... he could have been so famous the
second man on the moon is still famous now, but neil decided to live like
this. Alah aalam (god knows). if anyone else know about him i'd like to
know more.
wassalam
Here two postings on the newsgroup soc.religion.islam in response to the question and statement by Muslims at least informed that it is a rumor, ... yet Gilberto reporting on some other rumor he heard on how the original rumor might have started (rumors about rumors, getting ever more complicated):
From: gsimp95605@aol.com (GSimp95605)
Date: 1996/08/23
Message-Id: <4vkcdj$bfi@usenet.srv.cis.pitt.edu>
Newsgroups: soc.religion.islam
Asalam-alaikum,
What I've heard (some time ago, in this group) is that Neil Armstrong
went to Egypt, heard the adhan, said it was spacey" in an interview.
And somehow, that got turned into a rather nice story about how he
heard some strange sound when he was up in space, eventually found out
that it was the adhan, and became Muslim because of the experience.
To the best of my knowledge, he's not Muslim (allahu alim)
Salam
GIlberto
and
In article <50k5cg$lnt@usenet.srv.cis.pitt.edu>,
mas@crosfield.co.uk (Mas'ud Ahmed Khan) writes:
NO, this keeps popping up time and again, from what I gather
Neil Armstrong is not and was never a Muslim, he lives in the
US and is a bit of a recluse, he occasionally lectures.
Someone told me that he explicitly denied being a Muslim and
does not know how the rumour started.
It is sad that some Muslims make up stories that have a snowball
effect and sooner or later become a "fact" that Muslims boast
about can you imagine what impression we give to those who
know about Armstrong?
wa'as-Salaam
Mas'ud
In the following some statements about this issue, authorised by Mr. Armstrong, to speak on his behalf.
NEIL A. ARMSTRONG
LEBANON, OHIO 45036
July 14,1983
Mr. Phil Parshall Director
Asian Research Center
International Christian
Fellowship 29524 Bobrich
Livonia, Michigan 48152
Dear Mr. Parshall:
Mr. Armstrong has asked me to reply to your letter and
to thank you for the courtesy of your inquiry.
The reports of his conversion to Islam and of hearing
the voice of Adzan on the moon and elsewhere are all
untrue.
Several publications in Malaysia, Indonesia and other
countries have published these reports without verifi-
cation. We apologize for any inconvenience that this
incompetent journalism may have caused you.
Subsequently, Mr. Armstrong agreed to participate in a
telephone interview, reiterating his reaction to these
stories. I am enclosing copies of the United States
State Department's communications prior to and after
that interview.
Sincerely
Vivian White
Administrative Aide
Comments: In our possession is a photocopy of this letter which is identical in text to the above, except that the street address and phone number of Mr. Armstrong contained in that copy are deleted. The above also shows where this idea came from, that Mr. Armstrong supposedly lives in Lebanon. Yes, Lebanon is true, yet this "Lebanon" is not in the Middle East, but in the Midwest of the United States of America.
A statement by the US State Department sent to all embassies and consulates in the Islamic world:
P 04085 0Z MAR 83 ZEX
FM SECSTATE WASHD C
TO ALL DIPLOMATIC AND CONSULAR POSTS PRIORITY
BI
UNCLAS STATE 056309
FOLLOWING REPEAT SENT ACTION ALL EAST ASIAN AND
PACIFIC DIPLOMATIC POSTS DTD MAR 02.
QUOTE: UNCLAS STATE 056309
E.O. 12356: N/A
TAGS: PREL, PGOV, US, ID
SUBJECT: ALLEGED CONVERSION OF NEIL ARMSTRONG TO ISLAM
---------------------------------------------
REF: JAKARTA 3281 AND 2374 (NOT ..)
1. FORMER ASTRONAUT NEIL ARMSTRONG, NOW IN PRIVATE
BUSINESS, HAS BEEN THE SUBJECT OF PRESS REPORTS IN
EGYPT, MALAYSIA AND INDONESIA (AND PERHAPS ELSEWHERE)
ALLEGING HIS CONVERSION TO ISLAM DURING HIS LANDING ON
THE MOON IN 1969. AS A RESULT OF SUCH REPORTS,
ARMSTRONG HAS RECEIVED COMMUNICATIONS FROM INDIVIDUALS
AND RELIGIOUS ORGANIZATIONS, AND A FEELER FROM AT LEAST
ONE GOVERNMENT, ABOUT HIS POSSIBLE PARTICIPATION IN
ISLAMIC ACTIVITIES.
2. WHILE STRESSING HIS STRONG DESIRE NOT TO OFFEND
ANYONE OR SHOW DISRESPECT FOR ANY RELIGION, ARMSTRONG
HAS ADVISED DEPARTMENT THAT REPORTS OF HIS CONVERSION
TO ISLAM ARE INACCURATE.
3. IF POST RECEIVE QUERIES ON THIS MATTER, ARMSTRONG
REQUESTS THAT THEY POLITELY BUT FIRMLY INFORM QUERYING
PARTY THAT HE HAS NOT CONVERTED TO ISLAM AND HAS NO
CURRENT PLANS OR DESIRE TO TRAVEL OVERSEAS TO
PARTICIPATE IN ISLAMIC RELIGOUS ACTIVITIES.
Click here to view the scanned photocopy of
this above note from the US State Department.
Furthermore, the following letter to the editor was printed in the Journal Arabia, The Islamic World Review, Issue June 1985/Ramadan 1405, page 5:
A MUSLIM OVER THE MOON?
Arabia is by far the superior newsmagazine regarding
what is going on in the Muslim world today. Your reporting
is extremely thorough and seeks to be as objective as
possible. Your willingness to criticise political policies
as well as religious happenings in the Muslim world is
refreshing. As an American I would feel your slant on the
West is basically fair.
It would be most helpful if you would dispel a misconception
prevalent in almost all Muslim countries. From Morocco to the
Philippines it is commonly believed that Neil Armstrong heard
the Azan on the moon, converted to Islam and is now engaged in
the full-time propagation of the Muslim faith.
The US State Department has issued a memo saying that the story
about Armstrong's conversion was untrue. The memo said "While
stressing his strong desire not so offend anyone or show
disrespect for any religion, Armstrong has advised Department
that reports of his conversion to Islam are inaccurate." The
memo further says, "if post receives queries on this matter,
Armstrong requests that they politely but firmly inform querying
party that he has not converted to Islam and has no current
plans or desires to travel overseas to participate in Islamic
religious activities."
N.B. The memo was sent to all our diplomatic and consular posts.
Dr Phil Parshall
Director, Asian Research Centre Manila, Philippines
Click here for a
scanned image of this page in Arabia.
Sadly, as documented above, this rumor still goes round and round in the Islamic world, over a decade after it has been denied over and over again. Not only in mouth to mouth propaganda but it is even spread by Muslim radio stations.
Yet even when the Muslims tell their brothers that it is a false rumor, they are not convinced, the newest newsgroup tidbit is
Subject: Re: Neil Armstrong -first man on the moon!
From: Farzad
Date: 1997/01/17
Message-Id: <32df44f7.5655@showme.missouri.edu>
Newsgroups: alt.religion.islam
> No it is false, it is a myth spread in Muslim world. Armstrong denies
> this story. He is not Muslim ...
He perfomed prayers in Turkey in the same masjid where Malcolm X
prayed and huge crowd prayed behind him.
salaams,
Is this rumor ever going to die? My question to Farzad would be (as to all others who spread the rumor): Were you there when he prayed in this masjid? -- No? Thought so.
Response the above: [
Complaint], [Response]
But never shall they be satisfied ...
Anyway, this person gives at least some references for the rumors.
Subject: Re: Neil Armstrong - first man on the moon!
From: mdamron@aol.com (M Damron)
Date: 1997/02/02
Message-Id: <19970202002400.taa19712@ladder01.news.aol.com>
Newsgroups: alt.religion.islam
I thought he did convert. As an American that converted to Islam I have
come across this story in both Islamic and Non-Islamic sources. Two of
these include the book A Muslim Primer by Ira Zepp and another book titled
Defenders of God.
Without making any own claim as to its veracity: The
Jerusalem Christian Review (Volume 9, Issue 4) reports about a visit by Neil Armstrong as being a devout (Christian) believer (with more details in the full story).
Somebody sent me this response:
By the way, I heard from an authoritative source that Sheikh Omar Abdul Rahman has just announced that he has become an astronaut!
Rumors and HoaxesAnswering Islam Home Page